Making a comparison between mattresses brands can be very hard. With so many mattress brands in the market, sometimes it might seem you’re looking at the same circle repeatedly.
We’ve designed this mattress comparison to remove the sale tactics and marketing advice you’d often find in a typical brick and mortar mattress store.
Here we’ll be breaking down the Casper vs Tempurpedic online mattresses by looking at their construction, how they feel, and more.
We hope by the end of this comparison you would have all the information you require to make an informed purchase decision.
Casper vs Tempurpedic: Construction
In this section, we’ll uncover each mattress and reveal what’s underneath them.
The construction of the mattress will help you determine if a mattress will offer you the comfort, support, and pressure relief you desire. Without further delay, let’s dive in.
Casper mattress is constructed with 3 layers of foam: a top layer of aerated foam, a middle layer of zoned support, and a durable support layer featuring high-density polyfoam. This unique combination of materials creates a balanced medium feel.
As far as cover is concerned, Casper’s mattress cover is made of a knit polyester blend which features a softy and stretchy feeling. In case the cover gets stained, Casper recommends spot-cleaning with water and detergent.
Casper’s comfort layer features AirScape Perforated breathable foam, which helps in air circulation and facilitates the cooling.
This foam has a slow response to pressure, which permits sleeper to sink a bit for pressure relief at the hips and shoulders.
To mitigate overheating problems that can occur because of this countering. The material uses a perforated surface which promotes breathability and cooling throughout the comfort layer.
The comfort layer also is responsive and provides users with a light bounce.
The transition layer is where things get interesting. Instead of having a one thick memory foam layer like most all-foam mattress, it features a 2” zoned memory foam.
Zoned here means the layer has been divided into three different zones. Each zone provides varying levels of support and firmness for the different parts of the body.
The Zoned Support is firmer under the hips, waist, and lower back. But softer under the shoulder to support proper spine alignment and to provide balanced body countering as well as pressure relief.
The Casper’s foundation layer contains 7” of PCF high-density polyfoam. This dense foam provides the bed its shape and stability and prevents the sagging of the comfort layers.
The foundation layer reinforces the perimeter which protects the edges from sinkage in the specific places where the sleeper sits when getting in and out of the bed.
When looking at Tempurpedic bed construction, we’re going to focus on Tempur-Adapt the original Tempurpedic mattress.
In terms of cover, Tempur-Adapt comes with a cool-to-touch cover made of a premium knit technology.
The cover features antimicrobial treatment that offers mattresses protection against common allergens, including dust, dander, mite, and mold.
The Tempur-Adapt cover is not removable. The company suggests spot-cleaning of the cover fabric with water and mild detergent, in case a stain occurs.
The comfort layer of the all-foam Tempur-Adapt mattress comprises TEMPUR-ES foam, a proprietary material popular for its adaptive and body-contouring qualities.
The comfort layers offer sleepers substantial support and contouring. But it will probably sink a little beneath the surface, particularly if you weigh over 13 pounds.
According to most Tempurpedic bed reviews, the Tempur-Adapt transition layer comprises TEMPUR memory foam which is denser and prevents the sleeper from sinking too deeply into the bed.
Beneath the transition layer lies a high-density polyfoam designed to stabilize and support the whole mattress since its adaptable. The Tempur-Adapt mattress is not only stable but also durable.
Casper vs Tempur-Pedic: The Feel
You can’t shop for a mattress without knowing if it will support your sleep position and body type needs.
A mattress that works well for you back sleeper won’t work for your side-sleeping friend. Firmness and material matter.
So that’s why we’re taking our time to compare Casper and Tempurpedic mattress, to help you figure out which works best for you.
Back sleepers who fancy a softer feel will enjoy the Casper mattress. The comfort layer offers perfect body contouring, hence providing pressure relief to the lower back and hips.
The zoned support layers will provide sleepers with more hips support and prevent their midsections from sinking deeper into the mattress, causing spine misalignment.
However, strict back sleepers might find this mattress not firmer enough to prevent them from sinking in too deeply around their hips.
This could create pressure points and put their spine out of alignment. Therefore, they’re better off looking for another firmer option.
Casper’s conforming and pressure relief nature makes it a suitable mattress for side sleepers.
The comfort layers aerated foam contours to the side sleeper’s body to offer a pressure-relieving cradle.
The zoned layer prevents the side sleeper hips from sinking too deep into the mattress, thus promoting better spine alignment.
Lightweight side sleepers will most likely enjoy the perfect contouring and support balance being offered by Casper.
But heavier side sleepers might not love Casper’s medium firmness since it might allow them to sink too deep than they want.
This mattress is firm enough to support occasional stomach sleeping, but we won’t say it the perfect mattress for strict stomach sleepers.
Stomach sleepers often prefer a firm mattress which prevents their hips from sinking out of alignment with the shoulders.
But if you’re a lightweight stomach sleeper, this mattress might be okay for you. The Casper’s zoned layer will provide your midsection with extra support.
Tempurpedic- Tempur-Adapt mattress is rated below average for back sleepers. Most back sleepers find this mattress too soft, which causes them to sink too deeply, or wake up with lower back pain.
Lighter back sleepers might find this mattress medium feel comfortable since it conforms closely, meaning they won’t sink too much.
But anyone weighing above 130 pounds will most likely find this mattress soft. According to Tempurpedic reviews, they might also experience excessive sagging between their shoulders and hips.
This Tempurpedic model excels for side sleepers. It’s medium-firm and high conforming memory foam is perfect for individuals who sleep on their sides.
TEMPUR-Adapt foam permits the sinkage of the shoulder and hips. The foundation layer prevents the body from sinking in too deeply, thus maintaining a great balance of deep support, conforming, and comfort.
Stomach sleepers usually enjoy enhanced support for the midsection and gentle hugging for the head and legs.
Without the extra reinforcement, stomach sleepers tend to sag more as the weight from their hips and stomach gets pulled into the mattress. As a result, people experience shoulder and neck aches.
The TEMPUR-Adapt’s medium feel and enough sinkage isn’t great for stomach sleeping. Stomach sleepers weighing 230 pounds might find this mattress comfortable, but those weighing over 230 pounds will find the support of this mattress insufficient.
Casper Vs Tempurpedic: Sinkage & Bounce
The sinkage and bounce of a mattress will help you determine if the mattress will meet your body’s support needs. Also, it affects your sleeping positions during the night.
When sleeping on Casper’s original mattress you’ll notice a gentle hug. The soft memory foam layers will conform to your body and cradle it with minimum sinkage. Therefore, relieving pressure from your shoulder and hips.
The mattress top layer of high performance and sleep-specific latex foam, compliments the mattress countering with a little bounce.
Tempur-Adapt mattress is built to feel ultra-tight and allow you to enjoy deep hugging of memory materials around you.
While this is great for relieving pressure, it makes repositioning a bit difficult than on Casper. If this affects you, the Tempurpedic hybrid mattress with a coil system will add bounce and make changing positions easier.
Casper vs Tempurpedic: Other Models
Casper Lineup includes 4 mattresses other than the Casper original mattress. The mattress includes 2 hybrids and 2 all-foam options. Each mattress has a distinct internal construction, but all share a similar cover. Let’s have a look at some models:
Casper hybrid uses the same comfort and transition layers as Casper original, but the foundation layer of polyfoam is replaced with 6 inches of pocketed coils.
Because of the supported core, the Casper hybrid has high responsiveness when compared to Casper Original.
The Casper hybrid also provides sleepers with more edges support, all thanks to the dense foam around the coils. The coils feature a pocket design to reduce motion transfer.
Casper Nova Hybrid
This model is billed as Casper’s plushest mattress. Casper designed it as the next generation mattress.
Casper Nova hybrid ensures enhanced support for the lower back, thanks to the Zoned comfort layer.
Its transition layer is divided into 7 seven firmness levels for extra zoned reinforcement. The support also comes with 6” of pocketed coils encased in high-density foam.
Sleeper on a tight budget might find the Casper Nova Hybrid too expensive.
Casper’s Nova hybrid sleeps cooler than other models of Casper mattress since it engineered for cooling.
Casper Wave Hybrid
Casper Wave Hybrid is Casper’s luxury model.
It’s the most expensive Casper’s mattress, featuring special material for enhanced cooling, pressure relief, and support.
The Wave hybrid is constructed of 5 distinct layers. Four of its layers feature different proprietary foam which rests on a pocketed coils enclosed in foam for an additional counter, bounce, breathability, and edge support.
Casper Element was designed to provide shoppers of all budgets with an affordable mattress option.
It’s an all-foam mattress with 2 layers: 3” of AirScape polyfoam and 6.5” of base polyfoam.
The comfort layer of AirScape polyfoam gives this mattress a medium-firm feel, allowing it to deliver pressure relief to shoulder and lips and spinal alignment.
Just like Casper, Tempur-Pedic comprises an extensive line of mattresses, each with various add-ons and firmness options. They include both hybrid and all-foam options. Below, we’ve gone through some modes.
Tempur-Cloud is an all-foam mattress with a medium-firm. It’s among the cheap Tempurpedic mattresses sold by Tempur-Pedic.
It features a TEMPUR-comfort layer followed by a firmer support layer on top of its premium foam base.
This mattress was built for quick and easy delivery and is shipped in a recyclable box of a reusable canvas, making it the only bed-in- a- box option offered by Tempur-Pedic.
Tempur-ProAdapt comes with more firmness options, including soft, medium, and firm all-foam. There’s also a medium hybrid option.
While it might have the same construction as the Tempur-Adapt, it offers sleepers an additional foam layer customized to the firmness and to react to the body.
It’s an excellent choice for people who shift position a lot at night since its memory-foam sink is pronounced than that of Adapt.
Tempur-Pedic designed the Breeze model to mitigate heat retention common in some memory foam mattresses.
Because of the cooling feature, this Tempurpedic bed costs more than other models which might dissatisfy bargain-hunting shoppers.
The Breeze line includes the Tempur-ProBreeze, which claims to keep you feeling about 3 degrees cooler at night. Also, it includes Tempur-LuxeBreeze, which claims to keep you feeling about 8 degrees cooler all night.
Both the Tempur-Breeze lines have foam that’s the same in density to the other Tempur-Pedic mattress models.
Yes! that’s was lots of technical information, but bear with us a little more. In this section, we’ll look at another important factor that plays a key role when selecting the right mattress: Purchasing information.
Casper’s sleep trial period for all of its mattresses spans 100 nights long. There’s no mandatory break-in period, meaning you can return the Casper Mattress within the trial period and receive a full refund.
The company will offer a full refund and pick up the mattress. However, if you used White Glove Delivery service, you might not receive the extra cash they charged you for the service.
All Tempur-Pedic mattresses come with a 90–night sleep trial, but usually the company request customers to sleep of the mattress for 30 days as the break-in period before calming a refund.
When you make a return, Tempur-Pedic will pick up the mattress, but they will deduct a return shipping charge from your refund.
Casper and Tempur-Pedic feature the same warranty terms. For Casper, you’ll receive a 10-year warranty that forces the company to repair or replace the mattress once it becomes defective at no charge.
Tempurpedic mattress warranty is 10–years. The warranty features the repair and replacement of your defective mattress. Although the service is free, you’ll have to cover any shipping cost linked with the warranty claim.
Casper ships all its bed-in-a-box mattresses to 48 contiguous US states and Canada for free. You’ll receive your order within 5 business days, but some parts of the country are eligible for an expedited delivery for an additional charge.
Customers in Alaska, Hawaii, and selected international countries might incur additional shipping charges. The cost of White Glove delivery for all bed-in-a-box Casper mattresses is $149.
Tempur-Pedic bed-in-a-box Cloud mattress ships for free within all the contiguous states in the US. But shipping in Alaska and Hawaii comes at an additional cost. All Tempur-Pedic mattresses expect for Cloud mattress comes with free White Glove Delivery.
Casper Vs Tempur-Pedic: Which One to Buy
Now that you know all the factors you need to consider before buying a mattress: Construction, fell, sinkage & bounce, and Purchasing information. So… is Tempurpedic worth it or Casper?
We recommend you select Casper original mattress if:
- You’re a sleeper with sensitive pressure points: If you suffer from joint pain and aches, such as sore hips and shoulder, then Casper’s mattress zoned support will ease the pressure on the different parts of your body.
- You have a partner: If you find it hard to sleep with your partner because he/she continuously tosses and turns, then you’ll find Casper an ideal choice since it absorbs motion perfectly.
- You’re a stomach or back Sleepers: Casper original is the ideal mattress for stomach and back sleepers, who desire a contour layer that fits snugly without allowing too much sinkage.
Choose Tempur-Pedic if:
- You’re a combo sleeper: Combo sleepers will do very well on Tempur-Adapt. The mattress has moderate firmness makes it relatively adaptable for several varying sleeping preferences. It wins in a side-sleeping position, but many stomach and back sleepers will find it comfortable.
- You’re a lightweight sleeper: Tempur-Adapt performs well for lightweight sleepers since it possesses superior conforming, combined with a soft feel. Average weight sleeper between 130 to 230 pounds will also appreciate this mattress contouring and support.
- You’re ready to pay for a high-performance mattress: If you’re searching for a luxury mattress, Tempur-Pedic mattresses are your best option. They’re comfortable, efficient and deliver great pressure relief and support.
If you’re on a tight budget, you can take advantage of low price Casper mattress like Casper Element.
Casper Vs Tempur-Pedic: Price & Sizing
Both Casper’s original mattress and TEMPUR-Adapt comes with a diverse set of price points. In the table below you’ll find their retail price, before any discounts or promotions.
This will help you select a mattress within your budget limit, whether it’s the Tempurpedic twin mattress or Casper Queen mattress.
Which one is better? Tempur-Pedic or Casper?
Both these mattresses compete favorably. It’s hard to say which one is the best and which one is not.
If you need a mattress, that’s affordable, responsive, bouncy, and provides more lumbar support, you should select Casper’s original mattress. If you want a luxurious mattress with great pressure relief and durability, look no further than Tempur-Pedic mattresses.
What is the Tempur-Pedic Adapt made of?
Tempur-Pedic Adapt mattress is built with 3 layers of an improved version of Tempur-Pedic’s original memory foam.
- The first layer is a premium knit cool to touch cover.
- The comfort layer consists of Tempur-ES foam.
- The transition layer consists of adaptable foam made from an original Tempur memory foam.
- The foundation layer or support core is a high-density foam that provides the mattress with stability and increases its durability.
Connie finished her counseling psychologist program at Ohio State University. Her passion to write helped a lot of people suffering from physical, emotional, and mental issues.
Connie is a sleep specialist and a full-time writer for Sleep Standards. Connie has tested and reviewed over 40 different products and is always up to date on the latest sleep and mattress trends.